Investment Strategy
A brief history of interest rates
Xavier de Laforcade Partner
Head of portfolio management
Rothschild Martin Maurel
Without a doubt, the current economic and financial environment is replete with growing uncertainty, largely tied to the rapid changes in interest rates seen in recent years. After a decade of continuous rate cuts, which saw the Central Banks roll out ultra-accommodative monetary policies in order to support economic growth, the situation appears to have radically changed.
The shock wave triggered by the COVID-19 pandemic automatically led to spiking inflation, driving the Central Banks to take drastic measures in a bid to keep rising prices contained. The US Federal Reserve raised its key rate eleven times between March 2022 and July 2023, taking it from an initial range of 0%-0.25% to 5.25%-5.50%. A few months later, the European Central Bank followed suit, bringing the unprecedented era of negative key rates to an end in July 2022. As a result, its key rate gradually climbed from -0.50% to 4% in just over a year...
Within the last few months, however, having observed that inflation is nearing their target rate and that an economic downturn is all but confirmed by certain macroeconomic indicators, the Central Banks have initiated a rate cut movement. The European Central Bank has lowered its key rate twice since June, taking it to 3.50%. For its part, the Fed waited until September to launch its own rate cut movement, shaving 50 basis points off the fed funds rate, bringing it down to a range of 4.75%-5%.
This new interest rate trend has generated major consequences for investors, and not solely for the bond segment, but also in stocks, private equity(1) and real estate. In the circumstances, we believe it is important to try to understand not only the evolution of interest rates over time, but also the resulting implications for other market segments.
Looking back on a decade of interest rate cuts
The last fifteen years were undeniably marked by a unique period in financial market history, distinguished by a continuous decline in interest rates around the world.
This extended phase of low to even negative interest rates, in certain regions, began after the 2008 financial crisis, in turn linked to the explosion of subprime loans(2). In response to this shock, itself caused by interest rate products, the Central Banks decided to adopt ultra-accommodative monetary policies with the aim of stimulating an economic recovery. And, in addition to “traditional” key rate cuts, they set up quantitative easing policies(3) that saw massive quantities of cash injected into the financial system. This mainly consisted in buying up government bonds, public entity bonds and mortgage loans, thus setting the stage for favourable credit conditions spanning more than a decade.
Against this backdrop, investors and companies alike largely benefited from record-low financing costs. Meanwhile, the bond markets saw a sharp increase in supply, both from governments seeking to refinance their debt at a lower cost and from companies seizing the opportunity to raise cheap capital to fund their growth or extend the maturity of their debt. As a result, the level of negative-rate debt hit record highs during this period(4).
Investors wanting to play it safe massively bought up government and corporate bonds offering negative yields, which helped keep financing costs at exceptionally low levels.
At the same time, low rates made the search for yield easier, encouraging investors to turn to higher-risk assets, such as high yield bonds(5), equities or unlisted assets. Consequently, private equity funds (among others) benefited from a sharp rise in the number of investors as well as a significantly lower cost of capital, which shored up valuations.
Meanwhile, the real estate sector enjoyed the same momentum: with historically low borrowing rates, demand for residential and commercial real estate took off, attracting institutional and individual investors alike. This rise in demand caused real estate prices to climb, especially in large cities, where prices sometimes hit record levels(6). Low financing costs thus promoted growth in real estate prices, creating imbalances between the valuations and actual returns on assets, and increasing the risk of overheating the economy in some markets.
COVID-19 crisis
In 2020, the Covid-19 pandemic sent unprecedented shock waves across the global economy, forcing governments to launch massive economic stimulus plans and Central Banks to reactivate their QE programmes in an effort to prevent widespread economic collapse. However, this policy aimed at aiding the economic recovery gradually began to show its limits. Inflation, long contained below Central Bank targets, started to significantly gather pace in 2021. Rising commodity prices, disruptions in the supply chains of a heavily globalised economy, and increased demand which had been stifled during the different lockdown periods, all combined to drive inflation to never-before-seen levels on a global scale. After being held at floor levels for so many years, interest rates underwent a sudden turnaround.
In 2022, the Central Banks adopted much more restrictive monetary policies to address this rampant inflation. The Fed and the ECB thus began rapidly raising their key rates to combat inflation, marking the end of the low-rate era. This about-face deeply upset the financial markets, sending stock and bond prices tumbling. For many investors and companies, the rapid rise in interest rates put paid to a decade of exceptional conditions and shed light on new vulnerabilities, particularly in highly indebted sectors.
Paradoxically, despite these upheavals, credit spreads(7) stayed contained in this environment and still remain at historically low levels to this day. This resilience may prove surprising, given the contrast with the challenges met by a number of weakened sectors. There are multiple reasons for this scenario.
First, the huge cash injections implemented after the Covid-19 pandemic kept surplus capital in the financial system, facilitating access to credit for many companies. Second, economic stimulus plans like the Inflation Reduction Act(8) in the United States had a major impact on growth, helping to keep economic activity going strong in this rising interest rate environment.
The resilience of credit spreads is not fully representative of how the economy as a whole reacted. Some sectors, especially those highly dependent on financing, were extensively affected by rapidly rising interest rates. For example, the real estate sector both in Europe and China was among the hardest-hit sectors. In Europe, groups such as Adler and Signa were destabilised, while in China the failure of Evergrande uncovered the risks associated with excessive debt. One thing these companies shared in common was a weak financial structure, making it difficult to impossible to refinance their debt as interest rates rose.
“Ce contexte attendu de baisse des taux directeurs devrait se révéler porteur...”
As for the financial sector, it was also affected in 2023. In the US, regional banks Silicon Valley Bank and First Republic Bank filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, unable to withstand the run on deposits and general increase in financing costs. In Europe, the fall of Crédit Suisse, accelerated by scandals and management problems, also shone a spotlight on the fragility of certain banking institutions.
Lastly, some companies operating in “tech” sectors, in particular those not yet generating profits, also suffered in these new conditions. Companies like Peloton, which prospered in the wake of the pandemic amid low interest rates and abundant cash, saw their valuations plummet, making it much more difficult to keep their business model going in this type of environment.
Today, with inflation increasingly creeping up towards their target, the Central Banks have launched a rate cut movement at the very moment when the global economy is showing tangible signs of slowing. According to the PMI indices(9), economic activity is losing steam, particularly in the manufacturing sector, and employment data point to a gradual deceleration in the job market, especially in the United States. The financial markets thus now expect to see interest rates fall steeply by the end of the year and throughout next year, firmly believing that the Central Banks will do anything to bring the economy in for a soft landing...
And what about our investments?
Opportunities on the bond market, now largely consensual, are by no means recent and started to emerge in the second half of 2022. We have gradually increased the share of bonds in our portfolios since this period, mainly investing in maturity funds R-co Target 2028 IG and R-co Target 2029 IG, both invested exclusively in Investment Grade securities(10). We also bought government bonds in Europe and the United States, while increasing maturities as opportunities arose, to take maximum advantage of falling interest rates. With this approach, we were able to capture attractive yields at longer maturities, at a time when government and corporate bonds offered them. Euro-denominated funds have also done well in this high-rate environment. Insurers, with inflows fuelled by the abundance of cash, took advantage of higher interest rates to invest in high-quality bonds with high yields, exceeding those offered by their stocks of existing bonds. We would also add that the prospect of an interest rate cut is good for Euro funds, with bond valuations likely to appreciate in this type of environment.
Finally, a decrease in interest rates could stimulate lending, relax financing conditions for businesses and individuals, and thus ramp up economic activity in the medium term. Furthermore, the cost of variable-rate loans should also come down. We have been seeing the effects of the new “rate cut” cycle for several months now, if not several quarters, due to its anticipation by the financial markets. And the direct impacts on bond investments were soon to materialise. All in all, we think it is high time to react by substantially increasing our bond allocations now!
Although we do not expect interest rates to return to the levels seen just a few years ago any time soon, this projected interest rate movement should prove beneficial for long-dated bond investments, “growth” stocks, highly-leveraged listed companies, and private equity investments for some types of structure products.
Yes, the chapter of high interest rate tensions sparked by the Covid-19 crisis and its inflationary repercussions is well and truly closed. That said, the new chapter currently being written will be resolutely different from the 2008-2021 period: energy transition, government debt levels, “de-globalisation”, commodity prices... all point to a higher “floor” level of inflation than before. These are the very factors that promise to make this chapter both distinctly different... and exciting!
(1) Private Equity involves taking majority or minority shares in unlisted companies at any stage of their development.
(2) Subprime loans are loans granted to borrowers presenting a higher default risk, often due to poor solvency. These loans, particularly subprime mortgages issued in the real estate sector, are generally subject to higher interest rates so as to offset the increased risk.
(3) Quantitative easing is an unconventional monetary policy used by Central Banks to stimulate the economy. QE policies call for massive purchases of financial assets such as government or corporate bonds in order to inject cash into the financial system and bring down long-term interest rates.
(4) Negative rate debt reached the record level of $18,380 billion in December 2020 (Bloomberg).
(5) High Yield bonds are debt securities issued by companies or governments, with a rating lower than BBB- (S&P) or Baa3 (Moody’s). These bonds offer higher yields to offset the great risk of default associated with these less financially robust issuers.
(6) The index of Median Sales Price of Houses Sold for the United States reached its peak in Q4 2022 (Federal Reserve Bank of St Louis).
(7) Credit spreads measure the excess yield sought by investors to lend money to companies rather than governments. (8) Act adopted in the United States in 2022 aimed at reducing inflation. It includes fiscal measures, anti-climate change measures, and investments in clean energy.
(9) A Purchasing Managers’ Index contains economic indicators based on surveys of companies in the manufacturing and services sectors. They measure economic activity by looking at production, new orders, employment, delivery times and inventories. A PMI above 50 indicates economic expansion, while a PMI below 50 reflects contraction.
(10) Investment Grade bonds are bonds issued by companies or governments, with a rating above BBB- (S&P) or Baa3 (Moody’s), reflecting low default risk.